Protest against former Herald editor

21 November 2012,

Media Release:

Protest against former Herald editor

Global Peace and Justice Auckland will formally protest to Auckland University about former New Zealand Herald Editor Gavin Ellis being used to speak at a human rights forum this evening.

Ellis is singularly unsuited for this role. As editor of the Herald he presided over a paper which resolutely published Israeli-friendly propaganda while stifling the voices of Palestinian solidarity.

The most compelling example was his sacking of Herald cartoonist Malcolm Evans in 2003. Ellis firstly tried to stop Evans from drawing cartoons exposing Israeli hypocrisy – see example copied below where Ellis has scrawled a threat to Malcolm’s job on a cartoon before faxing it back.

When the treat failed Malcolm lost his job saying “my dismissal was a consequence of my refusal to accept the Editor’s claim that he had the right to direct my work.”

Ellis is therefore especially unsuitable to host a discussion on –

“how the media interact with psychological and cultural forces to impact perceptions, fears, peer-pressure, “groupthink,” and the creation of heroes and villains” or

“how the media were used to spread a contagion of hate in three deadly conflicts: Rwanda, Nazi Germany, and the former Yugoslavia…”

Ellis used his position as editor to reinforce Israeli propaganda of “Israel as hero – Palestinians as villains”.

Had the Herald taken a more balanced view in reporting the Middle East under Ellis we would not have the same depth of misunderstanding in New Zealand about the conflict there as we had in the 1970s about the situation in South Africa.

Ellis is entitled to his opinion even if it is indefensible. He is part of the media problem and should not be used by the university as some supposedly independent commentator on solutions.

John Minto 0220850161

Mike Treen 0295254744

2 Responses to Protest against former Herald editor

  1. Martin Hanson says:

    Like the U.K. and Australia, New Zealand is a vassal of the United States and, as such, does as it’s told. An important tool in this is control of the media. This was achieved by the CIA’s ‘Operation Mockingbird’, by which prominent individuals in the media were recruited to give the news the appropriate pro-US slant. Control of the corporate media is the first essential in the highly sophisticated ‘inverted totalitarianism’ of the United States.
    Only when people see such issues in the wider context can there be any hope of making progress.

  2. ewingsc says:

    Malcolm Evans was pushed out of his position as Cartoonist for the New Zealand Herald following complaints of ‘Anti Semitism’.

    He was twice voted cartoonist of the year 1999 and in 2003.

    Malcolm was also President of the NZCIA – cartoonists and illustrators association – the year he was sacked.

    His work is examined in this short documentary.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: